How Do You Aquire Goods And Services In A Moneyless Economy?

Cash is no longer king. In fact, economies that are more than greenbacks intensive tend to grow slowly and miss out on significant financial benefits. Conversely, economies that switch to digital are more successful; the switch can boost almanac Gdp past as much equally 3 pct points, BCG research shows.

Numerous examples around the world illustrate how cashless payments are economic propellers. People's republic of bangladesh'due south bKash, which enables transfers via mobile phones, has spurred growth and additional financial inclusion in that country. The upside comes non from more than money but from digital's role in simplifying the process of sending and receiving payments. Amid advanced economies, Sweden and South korea take moved steadily away from cash. (Greenbacks transactions in Sweden made upwardly less than two% of the value of payments in 2018, for example.) The result has been a shrinking grayness economy, booming online commerce, and a sharp reduction in fraud.

And yet, despite the show, at that place is little sign the world will go cashless anytime presently. Cash remains the world's most widely used payment instrument. Perhaps surprisingly, the global ratio of cash to Gross domestic product rose to ix.6% in 2018, compared with 8.i% in 2011. In Europe, fourscore% of bespeak-of-sale transactions are still conducted in cash. People have a strong emotional connection to notes, coins, and currency—and a lingering distrust of digital alternatives.

Slow progress toward cashless economies may be a source of frustration to policymakers, merchants, and fiscal institutions, all of which stand up to accrue benefits from digital. Notwithstanding, at that place are steps they can take. The correct strategies, incentives, infrastructure, and regulation can encourage innovation and boost public confidence in noncash systems. Partnerships, both public and individual, can also exist critical in marshaling expertise and creating momentum. The tools are in identify. All that is required to move forward is the will to human action.

The right strategies, incentives, infrastructure, and regulation tin can boost public confidence in noncash systems.

Cash Versus Digital

Despite huge growth in smartphone adoption and increasing demand for digital banking, the majority of countries remain heavily dependent on cash. Some 2 billion people globally do not have a bank account, showing that greenbacks remains essential to financial inclusion. And cash is entrenched in the economies of many developed markets. In the UK, the wide mensurate of coin supply, encompassing coins, notes, and cash-like instruments, reached £82 billion in tardily 2018, compared with about £68 billion iv years previously.

Cash is popular because it is user-friendly. Information technology is inclusive, trusted (it does not require intermediation by tertiary parties), accessible, and reliable. It doesn't require signal-of-auction (POS) technology and can't be hacked or undermined by a loss of ability, a cyber assault, or a system failure. Spending cash does non create a information betoken that might exist exploited for cross-selling.

Still, cash is inherently problematic. Undeclared payments in cash lead to taxation gaps, and there are costs associated with handling, press, transporting, and safeguarding cash. Ane major North American banking concern spends approximately $5 billion per year processing cash and check transactions and servicing ATMs. In the United kingdom, the cost of free-to-the-client ATM withdrawals is estimated at nearly £1 billion a year. Where ATM fees are charged, they are regressive, impacting lower-income demographics more than than others.

Cash is inherently problematic.

Payments using a carte du jour, app, or computer, conversely, are transparent, clean, and usually quite uncomplicated. No trips to the ATM are required, and there'southward no need to worry about carrying large amounts of cash in public. There is no price of treatment (although those savings are more than outset by card fees paid past merchants and indirectly by customers).

Further, because cards, apps, and other digital solutions make information technology easier to send and receive money, they increase economic activity and generate a wide array of fiscal and nonfinancial benefits.

BCG estimates that a move to a cashless model would add together nearly one percentage signal to the annual GDPs of mature economies and more than than 3 percentage points to those of emerging economies. (See Showroom 1.) One reason is that mobile money tin increase the velocity of value transfers. In addition, digital transactions provide more than transparency, making it easier to offering and obtain financing.

In an increasingly urbanized world, many cities (among them Bucharest, Seoul, Dubai, Madrid, and New York City) have introduced smart-city initiatives, leveraging digital to improve lives across a variety of parameters. Digital-payments engineering is part of that equation, and one study estimates that increasing digital payments in 100 leading cities could generate direct net benefits of $470 billion per yr. Small businesses in particular may benefit, with mobile payments enabling them to hire, purchase, and get paid more easily.

Cashless payments can assistance supervisors, central banks, and commercial banks practise better jobs. Electronic payments enable more comprehensive oversight and monitoring and tin can inform central banks' budgetary and economic policies. More visibility aids credit process direction, assuasive banks to make more-informed lending decisions. Cashless societies may also bring less obvious benefits: During the European sovereign debt crisis in 2012, some economists argued that moves by central banks to cut interest rates to below zero would be ineffective without a concurrent ban on cash. If people must pay to make bank deposits, it makes sense to keep money under the mattress.

Challenges in Making the Switch to Digital

Digital is an attractive culling where the cost of greenbacks is loftier (transport, ATM servicing, security, labor), where technology uptake is accelerating, or where the government struggles to collect sales tax. Numerous countries meet one or more of these criteria, according to an analysis in Harvard Business Review. They include developed markets such as France, Belgium, Espana, and Germany. Nonetheless, barriers to uptake remain. We have identified five principal areas of resistance. (See Showroom two.)

The High Cost of Electronic Payments. Electronic payments incur meaning fees and charges. The British Retail Consortium said in 2018 that, despite regulation of interchange fees, the all-in cost of digital payments had risen in 2017. UK retailers spent an additional £170 million to process card payments, for a total cost of almost £one billion. Increasing carte du jour costs were driven entirely by scheme fee increases, which rose 39%, measured as a percentage of turnover; the problem was exacerbated by limited market competition, the BRC said. Most payments systems are monopolies or duopolies.

A Lack of Customer-Axial Solutions. Payments solutions are oftentimes designed without customers' needs in mind and with a focus on applied science rather than user-friendliness. Many countries offer a fragmented patchwork of solutions that lack interoperability. In many cases, you lot cannot make a payment from ane brand of due east-wallet to some other. Consumers habitually need to carry multiple cards to come across their daily needs. Every bit a result, the penetration rates of person-to-person (P2P) solutions have remained relatively depression (beneath 15%) outside the frontier markets of Norway, Sweden, and Denmark.

Minimal Coordination Between Regime Entities. Lacking a fundamental dominance to drive transformation and coordination, projects are probable to neglect. In addition, a lack of proper governance, planning, and pedagogy on the implementation frontline is probable to result in fragmentation, hierarchy, and parallel processes.

Bereft Trust in Electronic Payments. Banks and companies are under rising pressure to protect their customers against cyber attacks. More than a few large companies with global operations have been hacked in contempo years, resulting in massive losses of customer data. The UK's national crime agency said in April 2018 that seven of the state's biggest banks reduced operations or close downwards systems following an attack the previous year. Ane reason is that, in many cases, attempts to increase cyber resilience do not proceed pace with the rapid uptake of digital payments.

In some countries, consumers are concerned virtually the bear upon of digital payments on the cost of living and their control over their own budget. Japanese consumers remain wedded to cash, for case, and visitors to the land are oftentimes struck by how many transactions are still conducted using notes and coins compared with neighboring China. Uptake in Frg is also relatively deadening.

The information created past digital transactions is a valuable commodity. It may bring significant benefits to companies, even though consumers in many countries experience a "trust gap" and are less certain of those benefits. Even in Sweden, the most cashless society globally (nearly three-quarters of all purchases are made by card), there are remainder doubts, especially over security. In early 2018, Sweden's primal bank governor, Stefan Ingves, urged his government to consider the vulnerability of the payment network in case of extreme circumstances.

The Absence of Supporting Infrastructure. Infrastructure is a fundamental element of a thriving payments ecosystem. Equally, its absence can be a hindrance. Rural areas in detail may not have infrastructure in place. In some places, there is a gender separate, with women excluded from internet admission. In many countries delays of two to 3 days in existent-time interbank transfers are mutual. The necessary standards to support infrastructure are too oft absent.

For a digital-payments organisation to take root, back up in the form of legal frameworks, electrical networks, and security is besides necessary.

How Policymakers Have Driven Uptake

In September 2016, the G20 heads of state and regime endorsed the Loftier-Level Principles of Digital Financial Inclusion (HLPs), recognizing the capacity of digital to assistance people become admission to financial services. Certainly, countries with dedicated digital policies and infrastructure have seen faster progress. Examples abound:

In Singapore, cashless payments took a major step forward in 2017 with the introduction of PayNow, a national real-time payment platform.
South Korea saw accelerating adoption after introducing end-of-year revenue enhancement credits for up to 30% of spending on debit cards.
Sweden has rolled out an assortment of policies encouraging cashless payments, from eliminating infrastructure such as ATMs while putting in identify enabling measures such every bit electronic know-your-customer (e-KYC) capabilities and real-fourth dimension payments and by granting stores the right to pass up cash. A tangential bear upon has been a surge in revenue enhancement receipts, with value-added tax ascension virtually 30% over five years.
The Reserve Bank of Australia has taken action to address the high cost of digital payments, capping interchange fees and putting a ceiling on card surcharges for small businesses. The moves led to a US$xi billion reject in merchant payment costs and an acceleration in the growth of card transactions. A similar cap in the US in 2011 led to an 8% rise in credit card usage.

An emerging grouping of "payments tigers" have also made specially rapid progress. Poland, for example, saw card transactions increase from fewer than 30 per capita in 2010 to approximately 125 in 2017, driven past initiatives such every bit Cashless Poland, a public-private partnership to back up cashless payments for modest businesses.
Numerous initiatives are underway in Africa. Ghana is digitizing with the aim of improving access to financial services, and Malawi has seen a abrupt rise in cashless transactions. Rwanda aims to go a cashless economy by 2024. In tardily 2018, the nation'southward fundamental banking company launched a regulatory sandbox for testing digital payment solutions.

Clearly, given the diverseness of economic systems around the world, there's no single solution that will guarantee a seamless transition. Still, several foundational elements raise the chances of a successful digital journeying.

Laying the Foundations

Laying the foundations for a cashless economy should typically brainstorm with a holistic and overarching national payments agenda, driven by a consortium of central stakeholders including the government, the key bank, financial institutions, consumer protection agencies, and merchants. The government should make up one's mind a timeline and a target stop country, based on a thorough cess of the technological, competitive, and regulatory landscape and benchmarking of functional requirements and enablers. (See "Enablers of a Cashless Economy" for 2 ways in which stakeholders tin back up an environment conducive to a cashless economy.)

Brainstorm with a holistic and overarching national payments calendar.

In addition to taking direct activity to upshot cashless transactions, stakeholders will benefit from helping to create an environs that is conducive to a cashless economy. Two areas of focus stand up out as existence particularly valuable.

Safeguarding of Consumer Interests. Consumer protection is vital. One regulatory initiative that addresses this issue is Europe's Full general Data Protection Regulation, which came into strength in May 2018. The GDPR has increased consumer confidence by requiring companies to safeguard consumer data and seek explicit permission for its commercial use. Government-mandated means of streamlining dispute resolution mechanisms would further bolster consumer protection and confidence, building comfort with the notion of a cashless economy.

An Ecosystem of Innovation. One in four fintechs globally is focused on payments. They bring with them, of course, a new focus on digital technologies. Several central banks are now evaluating the potential of these technologies, including blockchain and digital currencies, which may promote financial inclusion and increment efficiency through disintermediation and faster settlement cycles. Open-banking initiatives in many countries are encouraging collaboration between fiscal institutions and startups, leading to more than data sharing, increased cantankerous-selling, and the emergence of payments ecosystems.

Advisable governance and operational structures must be put in place. These would include establishing an overarching body to manage strategy and facilitate alignment and an operational committee to provide feedback and identify bug as projects motion forward.

Industry stakeholders should be closely involved, providing both technical and market expertise.

Finally, teams driving change need to exist multidisciplinary, bringing together skills and know-how spanning economics, technologies, and payments.

It makes sense to beginning small-scale, targeting low-value, high-frequency transactions. Still, it pays to think large in terms of collaboration and long-term implementation. BCG has identified five levers that tin drive the transformation procedure. (Come across Exhibit three.)

Plant the right incentives. Targeted incentives will encourage consumers and merchants to consider moving away from cash. This might be accomplished through reducing the cost of digital payments, introducing cash-handling charges, or restricting the use of greenbacks above sure thresholds (the EU is currently considering this final mensurate). In Sweden, a consortium of banks launched a free mobile payments app, which was adopted by fifty% of the population inside four years of launch.

PromptPay, the electronic payment service under the Thai government's due east-payment plan, encouraged uptake past removing charges for online banking. Chinese mobile payment leaders Alipay and WeChat Pay are engaged in an ongoing boxing to concenter users to their east-wallets, offering incentives that include greenbacks rebates, gratis bus rides, and even the gamble to win gold.

Governments and companies might also consider consumer-friendly schemes such as weekly prize drawings based on transaction IDs or systems with specific demographics in listen.

Encourage competition and ensure a level playing field. Competition naturally exerts down force per unit area on prices and encourages innovation, helping to offset the loftier cost of electronic payments. Measures to enable point-of-sale solutions are likely to aid, as are rules for transparency regarding fees. And governments can seek to actively back up innovation. The Britain, for example, offers enquiry and development tax relief and has introduced a number of revenue enhancement-related initiatives as part of the National Innovation and Scientific discipline Agenda, including for investors in startups. The country'southward Faster Payments Central Infrastructure is open to established banks and challengers and creates a mechanism for fintechs to access payment systems.

Some countries encourage competition by encouraging or enabling the creation of privately owned payment rails. This has long been the case in the The states, where The Clearing House operates several privately endemic payment track that integrate with the federally owned rails.

Provide world-class supporting infrastructure. Infrastructure is the primal enabler of a cashless payments model and should embrace the internet, mobile and payments technologies, regulation, security, and electricity networks. Governments should in parallel encourage innovations that promote real-fourth dimension interbank payments for retail transactions and strengthen operations through new business concern and operating models.

Already, some countries have transferred responsibility for payments infrastructures from key banks to individual companies or consortiums of banks. The U.k. Faster Payments Service, an initiative to reduce payment times between bank accounts, is run by privately owned Vocalink, for case. In 2018, a grouping of Australian financial institutions and the Reserve Depository financial institution of Australia launched the New Payments Platform, which is based on ISO 20022 messaging formats and enables consumers, businesses, and government agencies to brand real-time, data-rich payments between accounts. And Hong Kong and Singapore, among others, have built multicurrency payment systems for interbank transfers, strengthening their positions as global trading hubs.

Streamline and enforce regulations. Targeted and proportional regulation tin strengthen conviction in electronic payments and enforce financial inclusion. Initiatives such equally rapid dispute resolution mechanisms, licensing schemes, and fee caps have been highly effective in boosting the uptake of cashless solutions.

A stiff and proactive regulator is essential. For example, the US regulator made a large push afterward ix/eleven to enforce an electronic check exchange standard. If the regulator does not make this kind of effort (for example, in real-time payments), everything takes longer.

Partner with the private sector. Policymakers should seek to collaborate with stakeholders to foster innovation; already around the world many are doing so. Thai state authorities, for example, have joined with the private sector to launch the National east-Payment Main Program. The plan's PromptPay initiative enables interbank fund transfers using mobile phones and has signed upwardly more than 2 million merchants to QR-code payment. In Europe, the Cashless Poland Foundation provides small and medium-sized retail businesses with point-of-sale terminals and subsidizes them to take low-value card payments, which otherwise might not be cost-effective. Noncash payments in Russia grew from approximately 25 per capita in 2010 to roughly 150 in 2017, amid collaboration between banks and regime. Russia's Sberbank, with its 55% market share, employed 10,000 run across-and-greeters in banking concern branches to provide information and encourage adoption.

Equally digital lifestyles expand and more people around the world get continued, it makes sense that payment systems will adapt. Consumers, companies, and governments stand to benefit, and the rising of e-commerce requires an efficient electronic payments infrastructure. However, after thousands of years of fiat currencies, policymakers and corporate leaders should non underestimate the challenges. The solution should be a holistic approach, comprising the right infrastructure, legal frameworks, technologies, and a willingness to partner and interact. The task is complex, simply the prize is faster growth and an economy enabled for the time to come.

Authors

About Boston Consulting Group

Boston Consulting Group partners with leaders in business concern and social club to tackle their well-nigh important challenges and capture their greatest opportunities. BCG was the pioneer in business strategy when it was founded in 1963. Today, we work closely with clients to embrace a transformational approach aimed at benefiting all stakeholders—empowering organizations to grow, build sustainable competitive reward, and drive positive societal impact.

Our diverse, global teams bring deep industry and functional expertise and a range of perspectives that question the status quo and spark alter. BCG delivers solutions through leading-border direction consulting, applied science and design, and corporate and digital ventures. We work in a uniquely collaborative model across the firm and throughout all levels of the customer organization, fueled past the goal of helping our clients thrive and enabling them to make the world a meliorate place.

For data or permission to reprint, delight contact BCG at permissions@bcg.com. To find the latest BCG content and annals to receive eastward-alerts on this topic or others, please visit bcg.com. Follow Boston Consulting Group on Facebook and Twitter.